It is a sad fact that today in our country, our communities are suffering from myriad health issues, many of which are related to diet. Unfortunately, our children are not immune. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 17 percent of children and adolescents ages 2-19 are obese (2009). In her book for teens entitled Food and You, Sharon Zoumbaris points out the percentage of overweight adolescents has more than doubled in the last 30 years. As a country, we spend 240 billion health care dollars yearly on obesity related conditions(Zoumbaris). If the number of children over a healthy weight does not begin to decline, health care costs will continue to rise right along with the increasing incidence of overweight children. As part of a multifaceted solution, the recent interest in community gardens throughout the country has something to offer in the way of change. Although all age groups stand to benefit from this gardening renaissance, children are the most important element in the health of any community. Habits fostered in our children today have a direct impact on future generations. In order to turn our current health crisis around, we must take steps to nurture a love for gardening in children and the rewards will be reaped for years to come.
The poor eating habits in our youth today are apparent when you pay attention to the most popular foods in the average grocery store. All you have to do is compare the number of highly processed foods to those of whole foods in the aisles. You may notice that the aisles are full of processed foods, and the perimeter of the store is where the more whole foods such as vegetables, meats, and dairy are located. The more processed foods are also specially placed within the eye level of a person of shorter stature (kids), to take advantage of the 'I Want It' factor. As a parent it is often easier to succumb to the demands of a toddler than deal with the temper tantrum in public that can happen when that child is denied what they want. If we look at the nutrition label of any popular kids breakfast cereal, we may find a minimum of 2 types of processed sugar, most commonly corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup. These highly processed types of sugar are also commonly used in many of the children's snacks that are widely advertised and directly promoted to kids. Younger children consuming an excess amount of sugar, especially refined sugar, has been linked as one of the common causes for Type 2 diabetes, which is increasingly being reported among kids who are obese. Normally, this type of diabetes stems from glucose intolerance, a common cause of adult (Type 2) diabetes. Only in recent years has it emerged as a health problem in adolescents. Early onset of Type 2 diabetes can result in advanced complications such as Cardiovascular Disease(CVD) and kidney failure (CDC). As Eric Schlosser points out in his book Fast Food Nation, in addition to early onset diabetes, severely obese children in America are dying from heart attacks caused by their weight (242). Children, dying from heart attacks! Negative health effects are just one of many problems poor eating habits can cause for our younger population.
Growing up can be hard, a fact we may all be aware of. Kids can be mean, whether they mean to be, or not. Some of the experiences we have in adolescence inevitably follow us through to adulthood. Kids who are overweight are often the target for bullying, which may cause a permanently negative relationship with food. For a fitting analogy we can look at weeds; when these unwanted seeds are planted, weeds take root. Often times, a lot of hard work is required to get rid of them completely. Like weeds, teasing and taunting by our peers during adolescence can result in low self-esteem that can carry on into adulthood. Pressure to fit in and be accepted by our peers seems to be part and parcel of growing up. These so called 'awkward years' can become hellish when combined with the social stigma of obesity. As as an additional result, low self-esteem can put unnecessary stress on social development and hinder academic progress (CDC).
Eating well has indeed become a challenge. Part of the problem with the diet of young Americans is more than 84% of them eat too much fat, and 91% eat too much saturated fat. Only one in five young people eats the recommended daily servings of fruits and vegetables. 51% percent of children eat less than one serving of fruit per day and 29% eat less than one serving a day of vegetables that are not fried (Zoumbaris). The fundamental basis of a good diet is to eat a wide variety of foods. Anyone who has children knows this can be a particular challenge. Our kids have the tendency to be picky eaters, and will sometimes prefer the same foods over and over if they are not encouraged to try new things. It is a vicious cycle which can be broken, especially if we are willing to find creative methods. In order to effect the eating habits of our children we must find a way to make healthy eating fun for them.
Many fast food outlets in the Unites States recognize the fact that eating should be fun for kids. For example, McDonald's restaurants have offered a prize in their kids Happy Meals since they began to offer them. This enticement may contribute to many children becoming fast food addicts, due to the fact that “a taste for fat developed in childhood can be difficult to loose as an adult” (Schlosser 241). Our tendency to crave fatty foods was born from a need for survival in a world where we as humans had to hunt and travel on foot for miles searching for food. In today's world of convenience foods, this survival tendency has become obsolete ( Richardson). We can easily ingest an entire days worth of calories in just one fast food meal. Soft drinks alone available in fast food restaurants can provide 310 calories for a 32 ounce serving. Additionally, for a large size of french fries, (which does not even qualify as a serving of vegetables) you get 610 calories, and 29 grams of fat. This amount is nearly half the recommended daily allowance (RDA) for fat intake in one side order of fries! These numbers may be shocking, yet every second 200 Americans continue to order one or more meals at a fast food chain (Zoumbaris). The truth is it can sometimes be more economical and convenient to feed a family of four at a fast food outlet. A family of four can be fed for about ten dollars at McDonald's. No shopping, or preparation is required, and there is little mess to clean up. In contrast, buying fresh vegetables and preparing them at home can cost more money, and take significantly more time (Schlosser).
Time spent preparing nutritious foods may be one factor in what keeps people from eating well, and availability may be another factor. Poorer communities in our country have become what has been termed 'food deserts' in a journal study by the Rural Sociological Society titled: Food Deserts and Overweight Schoolchildren, Evidence from Pennsylvania, by Kai Schaft,, Eric Jensen, and Clare Hinrichs, who found that in more densely populated areas there is little access to grocery stores which offer a wide selection of foods within a reasonable (walking) distance. What seems to be readily available in a food desert are convenience stores and fast food outlets, which offer calorie dense, yet nutrient deficient choices, with little to no healthy options. Having easy access to foods may help determine what types we choose to purchase and consume (429). Typically, when there are healthful options in a convenience store they can come at a high price, sometimes fetching one whole dollar for just a single banana. When given the choice to spend one dollar it is easy to see how anyone could pick a bag of chips or a hot dog over a simple piece of fruit.
Our public schools are not helping to encourage healthy eating in schoolchildren. Visit most any public school, and you will find vending machines full of junk foods, including soft drinks and snacks offering excess salt in place of valuable nutrition. This is not taking into consideration the highly subsidized school lunches that have come into focus recently with popular British chef Jaime Olivers new television series, Food Revolution. His show makes it clear that it is not only the kids who are resistant to change. The school cooks have become accustomed to the easy to prepare/mass produced foods they pull from the freezer and cook en mass for the hundreds of hungry students, all in about an hour. Preparing healthy foods on such a large scale would be an intimidating challenge for any chef. This popular television show makes clear the fact that affecting change on the large scale of our public schools will be a bigger challenge than many of us are ready, or willing, to face. There have been a few attempts in recent years to limit what foods are offered in school vending machines. These have mostly failed, (with the exception of a few schools in the state of California) due to the fact that revenue can be fetched by the machines, which goes directly to benefit cash strapped schools. Fast food chains such as Pizza Hut have even begun to pop up in school cafeterias. Creative solutions have become necessary, so far they just haven't been the healthiest solutions.
Creative alternatives are cropping up out of the need for better access to healthy foods in our schools. In her book titled Fed Up!, Sharon Okie mentions a schoolyard garden project grown from the passions of Chef Alice Waters, and a visionary public school principal in Berkeley, California named Neil Smith. Since it began in 1995, the Edible Schoolyard has blossomed into a blueprint for education reform in the arena of food access and ecological education. This concept has since transformed a resource poor junior high school into a revolutionary learning environment. The garden and kitchen at Martin Luther King Middle School in Berkeley CA, has become an unconventional classroom where education in biology, nutrition, horticulture, environmental education, cooking, and group participation integrate. More than 600 students spend 90 minutes of class time every week in either the schools kitchen or garden. These students learn to grow, prepare, and eat the fruits and vegetables from the schoolyard garden. Learning math goes hand in hand with preparing the fertilizer. Teamwork comes into play when the kids get to decide what to prepare in the kitchen. They learn knife safety while learning to chop vegetables. Watching the vegetables grow from seedlings teaches the wonders of nature. Cooperation is learned when dividing up chores in the garden. These kids learn that good things can come from hard work. The opportunities in the Edible Schoolyard provide these children, many of which rarely get to sit down at the table with their families, a chance to cook, set the table, and enjoy a meal together. During weeks of standardized testing, the students prepare a feast for their families and teachers, making them excited to share their knowledge and impress their parents. Parents often remark how their child was never excited about vegetables before their experience in the schoolyard garden (Okie).
Though the focus in the Edible Schoolyard is not entirely on nutrition, these kids are learning what to eat, and when to eat it according to season. In addition, they are given a reason to be interested in the food that they eat. When you plant a seed and watch it grow, learn to chop it and how to prepare it, an intimacy occurs. These children know what the vegetables are, and are encouraged to try them based on the investment they have put into the individual foods production. Alice Waters believes that the food and drink children receive at school teaches them silent but powerful lessons. When we try to encourage healthy lifestyles in the classroom, but the hidden curriculum about food is not consistent, the children receive mixed messages. While the fast food lunch options, and steady supply of junk foods in our schools may mirror the typical eating habits of an American family, it is reinforcing unhealthy habits in our children. Simply educating them about healthful foods can make a real difference in their eating habits. In one study, students at a New York elementary school received lessons about plant based foods such as bulgur wheat, various greens, and black eyed peas. When these foods were then offered in the cafeteria, the informed students chose them 3-20 times more than the control group, who had not received the lessons (Okie).
The Edible Schoolyard at Martin Luther King Middle School is not the only project focused on a more ecological education. Students at Rosa Parks Elementary School in San Diego, CA, enjoy the benefits of a community garden right on their campus. The school district worked with the City of San Diego in order to obtain a parcel of land as an educational garden. Plans for the garden were created by the students, allowing the children to decide types of vegetables they would like to grow, as well as what types of perennials to plant to attract butterflies. Students are responsible for the care of the garden, and the harvests are then distributed (at a low cost) to the students families in a school run farmers market. In an area where 54.5 % of families earn incomes below the poverty level, this has been an encouraging prospect. When the students learn to garden, they have a renewed excitement for the regular lesson plans in the school. And in turn, they take these lessons home to their families (Okie).
In an article by Dorothy Blair in the journal of Environmental Education, Blair observes that experiential learning, the type that happens in an outdoor setting with direct contact with natural things, provides an experience that enriches the educational process. Nature changes rapidly, attracting and stimulating a childs attention. It is also way of giving kids a fascinating new way to look at life. Integrating math, writing, and social studies with the garden schoolyard, has reshaped the overwhelming amount of factual knowledge that may keep some kids from succeeding in areas such as critical thinking and processing skills (Blair). Gardening is not necessarily easy, teaching young kids that sometimes good things in this life require work. Harvesting the vegetables is reaping the rewards, teaching students that hard work will pay off. Learning how a plant goes from seed to plate, and eating vegetables when they are in season, is a valuable lesson in not only nutrition, but also about the food system ecology. Ask a young child of 9 where their banana came from and you might get an answer like, “ The store.” Explain to them that bananas only grow in far away places and you may get a stunned look. Many children have no sense of place within their food dynamic, and giving kids this sense of place is a valuable tool in allowing for a healthier attitude about food.
Throughout time, culture has depended on education as a means to preserve traditions. Schools are social laboratories. Educators have often used the educational system to affect a change in society. With the current school lunch options available in the country, we are raising a generation of kids with little to no knowledge about the food they eat and where it comes from. Schoolyard gardens are one solution with many positive possible outcomes. If we, as a community, work together with school districts and local governments, we could bring about a dynamic change in the lifestyles, learning habits, and of course, the eating habits of our children. As the cherry on top, children could adopt a new viewpoint on what it means to be a part of something bigger than themselves. Community gardens have the capability to bring communities and families together in a way we have historically gotten together most often, at the table. Without a significant change in our schools, we are currently raising a generation, who will in turn raise the next generation with little or no valuable food knowledge.
"Without health life is not life; it is only a state of languor and suffering - an image of death."
---Buddah
Bibliography
Bijlefeld, Marjolijn, and Sharon Zoumbaris. Food and You. Greenwood
Publishing Group, 2001. 1-2..
Print.
Blair, Dorothy. "A Child in the Garden: An Evaluative Review of the
Benefits of School Gardening." Journal of Environmental Education. 40.2
(2009): 15-20. Print.
Childhood Overweight and obesity. Web. 7/25/2010.
Hutchison, David. Growing Up Green : Education for Ecological Renewal .
NYC, New York: New York Teachers College Press, 1998. 131,132,133.
Print.
Kai A., Schafft, Eric B. Jensen, and C. Clare Hinrichs. "Food Deserts
and Overweight Schoolchildren: Evidence from Pennsylvania." Rural
Sociology 74.2 (2009): 153-177. Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 24
July 2010.
Okie, Susan. Fed Up! : Winning the War against Childhood Obesity .
Washington, D.C : National Academies Press, 2005. 184-189. Print
Schlosser, Eric. Fast Food Nation : The Dark Side of the All-American
Meal Boston, Mass.: Boston Houghton-Mifflin , 2001. 241-242. Print.
Amy,
ReplyDeleteThis is an excellent paper. You established in your introduction the purpose and the audience. You cited good sources, you did it correctly, and you used them as support rather than to carry your whole paper. Your conclusion was meaningful and not just a summary of what you already wrote. Your research itself was varied and interesting. Great work. :)
150/150
Final Grade: 95% (A)